Fairness in employment testing : validity generalization, minority issues, and the General Aptitude Test Battery / John A. Hartigan and Alexandra K. Wigdor, editors ; Committee on the General Aptitude Test Battery, Commission on Behavioral and Social Sciences and Education, National Research Council.

Author
National Research Council (U.S.). Committee on the General Aptitude Test Battery [Browse]
Format
Book
Language
English
Εdition
1st ed.
Published/​Created
Washington, D.C. : National Academy Press, 1989.
Description
1 online resource (368 p.)

Details

Subject(s)
Bibliographic references
Includes bibliography: p. 291-300 and index.
Contents
  • Fairness in Employment Testing
  • Copyright
  • PREFACE
  • CONTENTS
  • SUMMARY
  • Issues for Study
  • Issues in Policy, Equity, and Law (Chapters 1, 2, and 13)
  • Findings and Conclusions
  • Is the Psychometric Quality of the GATB Adequate? (Chapters 4 and 5)
  • How Well Does the GATB Predict Job Success? (Chapter 8)
  • Does the GATB Predict Less Well For Minority Job Seekers? (Chapter 9)
  • Are There Scientific Justifications for Adjusting Minority Test Scores? (Chapter 13)
  • Is the GATB Valid for Some, Most, or All Jobs? (Chapters 6 and 7)
  • Will Increased Use of the GATB Result in Substantial Increases in Productivity? (Chapter 12)
  • Potential Effects of the VG-GATB Referral System (Chapters 10 and 11)
  • When Should the GATB Not Be Used? (Chapter 11)
  • Summary of Central Recommendations
  • Operational Use of the VG-GATB Referral System
  • Referral Methods
  • Score Reporting
  • Promotion of the VG-GATB Referral Program
  • Pilot Studies
  • Special Populations
  • Veterans
  • People with Handicapping Conditions
  • PART I BACKGROUND AND CONTEXT
  • 1 The Policy Context
  • THE USES EMPLOYMENT TESTING PROGRAM
  • Within-Group Scoring of the VG-GATB
  • The Justice Department Challenge to Within-Group Scoring
  • OTHER POLICY ISSUES
  • Validity Generalization and the Reemergence of g
  • Early IQ Testing
  • The Army Alpha
  • Critics of Intelligence Testing
  • Relevance to Current Policy
  • Should There Be Diverse Routes to Employment?
  • THE INTERSECTIONS OF POLICY AND SCIENCE
  • 2 Issues in Equity and Law
  • PERSPECTIVES ON EQUALITY, FAIRNESS, AND SOCIAL JUSTICE
  • Philosophical Foundations
  • Economic Liberalism
  • Meritocracy.
  • Meritocracy Revisited
  • The Contemporary Impasse on Preferential Treatment
  • The Case Against Preferential Treatment
  • The Case for Preferential Treatment
  • Beyond Philosophy
  • FEDERAL POLICY AND PREFERENTIAL TREATMENT
  • Individual Rights, Group Effects, and the Law
  • Equity and Equal Protection Jurisprudence
  • Affirmative Action
  • PERSPECTIVES ON WITHIN-GROUP SCORING
  • 3 The Public Employment Service
  • HOW DO AMERICANS FIND JOBS?
  • HISTORICAL DEVELOPMENT OF THE PUBLIC EMPLOYMENT SERVICE
  • Beginnings
  • The New Federalism
  • Funding Levels
  • STRUCTURE OF THE SYSTEM
  • USES: The Federal Partner
  • State-Level Activities
  • Local Offices
  • OPERATIONS AT THE LOCAL LEVEL
  • Activities Common to All Offices
  • Profile One: A Traditional Office
  • Profile Two: A VG-GATB Office
  • Profile Three: The Single-Employer Office
  • Implications of Local-Office Procedures
  • PART II ANALYSIS OF THE GENERAL APTITUDE TEST BATTERY
  • 4 The GATB: Its Character and Psychometric Properties
  • DEVELOPMENT OF THE GATB
  • THE STRUCTURE OF THE GATB
  • Subtest 1: Name Comparison
  • Subtest 2: Computation
  • Subtest 3: Three-Dimensional Space
  • Subtest 4: Vocabulary
  • Subtest 5: Tool Matching
  • Subtest 6: Arithmetic Reasoning
  • Subtest 7: Form Matching
  • Subtest 8: Mark Making
  • Subtest 9: Place
  • Subtest 10: Turn
  • Subtest 11: Assemble
  • Subtest 12: Disassemble
  • HOW GATB SCORES ARE DERIVED
  • Obtaining GATB Scores
  • GATB Norms
  • Norms for Within-Group Scoring
  • Equating Alternate Forms of the GATB
  • RELIABILITY OF THE GATB APTITUDE SCORES
  • CONSTRUCT VALIDITY ISSUES
  • COMPARISON WITH THE ASVAB AND OTHER TEST BATTERIES
  • ASVAB Test Parts
  • Speededness of the ASVAB
  • ASVAB Normative Data
  • ASVAB Reliabilities
  • ASVAB Validities
  • CONCLUSIONS
  • GATB Properties
  • Comparison with Other Test Batteries
  • RECOMMENDATIONS.
  • 5 Problematic Features of the GATB: Test Administration, Speededness, and Coachability
  • TEST ADMINISTRATION PRACTICES
  • Instructions to Examinees
  • The National Computer Systems Answer Sheet
  • THE INFLUENCE OF SPEED OF WORK
  • ITEM-BIAS ANALYSES
  • Proportion Attempted
  • Proportion Correct
  • Point-Biserial Correlations
  • PRACTICE EFFECTS AND COACHING EFFECTS
  • Effects of Practice on GATB Scores
  • Effects of Coaching on GATB Scores
  • TEST SECURITY
  • Test Administration Practices
  • Speededness
  • Alternate Forms and Test Security
  • Item Bias
  • Practice Effects and Coaching
  • RECOMMENDATIONS
  • Test Security
  • Test Speededness
  • PART III VALIDITY GENERALIZATION AND GATB VALIDITIES
  • 6 The Theory of Validity Generalization
  • META-ANALYSIS
  • VALIDITY GENERALIZATION
  • The Theoretical Framework
  • Sampling error
  • Restriction of range
  • Reliability of supervisor ratings
  • Connecting the sample to the population
  • Sampling Error
  • Corrections for Sampling Error
  • An Example
  • Restriction of Range
  • Corrections for Restrictions of Range
  • Estimating Restriction Ratios
  • Can GATB Restriction Ratios be Estimated?
  • Reliability of Supervisor Ratings
  • Connecting the Sample to the Population
  • THE INTERPRETATION OF SMALL VARIANCES IN VALIDITY GENERALIZATION
  • Adjustments to Validity Coefficients
  • Range Restriction
  • Criterion Unreliability
  • 7 Validity Generalization Applied to the GATB
  • CRITERION-RELATED VALIDITY RESEARCH AND VALIDITY GENERALIZATION
  • REDUCTION OF NINE APTITUDES TO COGNITIVE AND PSYCHOMOTOR FACTORS
  • GATB Dimensions
  • What Gets Lost in the Simplifying Process?
  • THE FIVE JOB FAMILIES
  • Constructing the Five Job Families
  • Sample Jobs in the Job Families:.
  • Do the Five Job Families Effectively Increase Predictability?
  • 8 GATB Validities
  • THE GATB VALIDITY STUDIES
  • An Illustration of Test Validities
  • Basic Patterns of Validity Findings
  • Potential Moderators of Validity
  • Sample Size
  • Job Family
  • Study Type: Predictive Versus Concurrent
  • Criterion Type: On-the-Job Performance Versus Training Success
  • Age
  • Experience
  • Education
  • Validity Differences by Race
  • Validity Differences by Sex
  • Date of Study
  • Exploration of Explanations for the Change in Validity Over Time
  • VALIDITY GENERALIZATION ANALYSES
  • Correcting Only for Sampling Error
  • Correcting for Criterion Unreliability
  • Correcting for Range Restriction
  • Optimal Predictors Based on the Recent 264 Studies
  • FINDINGS: THE GATB DATA BASE
  • Criterion-Related Validity Prior to 1972
  • Criterion-Related Validity Changes Since 1972
  • CONCLUSIONS ON VALIDITY GENERALIZATION FOR THE GATB
  • Observed and Adjusted Validities
  • Validity Variability
  • 9 Differential Validity and Differential Prediction
  • GROUP DIFFERENCES IN CORRELATIONS
  • DIFFERENTIAL PREDICTION
  • Standard Errors of Prediction
  • Slopes
  • Intercepts
  • Predictions Based on the Total Group
  • Performance Evaluation and the Issue of Bias
  • Differential Validity by Race
  • Differential Prediction by Race
  • Criterion Bias
  • PART IV ASSESSMENT OF THE VG-GATB PROGRAM
  • 10 The VG-GATB Program: Concept, Promotion, and Implementation
  • CONCEPTUAL MODEL OF THE VG-GATB REFERRAL SYSTEM
  • Group Orientation and Registration
  • GATB Testing
  • File Search and Referral
  • Office Automation
  • Comment on the Conceptual Model
  • PROMOTION OF THE VG-GATB REFERRAL SYSTEM
  • The Legal Implications
  • IMPLEMENTATION OF THE VG-GATB REFERRAL SYSTEM: THE PILOT STUDIES
  • North Carolina Study of Office Effectiveness.
  • North Carolina Employer Survey
  • The Philip Morris Study
  • The Chrysler Corporation Study
  • The Sewing Machine Operator Study
  • CONCLUSIONS AND RECOMMENDATIONS
  • Promotion of the VG-GATB Referral System
  • Conclusions
  • Recommendations
  • Implementation of the VG-GATB Referral System: The Pilot Studies
  • Findings
  • 11 In Whose Interest: Potential Effects of the VG-GATB Referral System
  • EFFECTS ON EMPLOYERS
  • An Informal Survey of Employers
  • How Respondents Use the VG-GATB Referral System
  • Attitudes Toward the VG-GATB Referral System
  • Equal Employment Opportunity and Affirmative Action
  • Possible Negative Effects
  • EFFECTS ON JOB SEEKERS
  • Logistics
  • Perceptions of Fairness
  • Low-Scoring Applicants
  • Older Applicants
  • EFFECTS ON MINORITY JOB SEEKERS
  • Assessing Applicants Who Have Marginal English Skills
  • EFFECTS ON PEOPLE WITH HANDICAPS
  • Recent Research Findings
  • Experience with the GATB
  • Should Handicapped Applicants Take the GATB?
  • EFFECTS ON VETERANS
  • The History of Veterans' Preference
  • Civil Service examinations
  • Eligibility lists
  • Civil Service appointments
  • The Public Employment Service and Veterans' Preference
  • Veterans' Priority in Referral
  • Veterans and Within-Group Score Adjustments
  • FINDINGS, CONCLUSIONS, AND RECOMMENDATIONS
  • Employers
  • Job Seekers
  • 12 Evaluation of Economic Claims
  • UTILITY ANALYSIS: GAINS FOR THE INDIVIDUAL FIRM
  • Potential Benefits of Employment Service Use of the VG-GATB
  • Will VG-GATB Testing Save 80 Billion?
  • GAINS TO THE ECONOMY AS A WHOLE ARE FROM JOB MATCHING
  • Economic Gains Based on the Hunter and Schmidt Job- Matching Model.
  • SUPERVISOR RATINGS AND TRUE PRODUCTIVITY.
ISBN
  • 1-280-21455-4
  • 9786610214556
  • 0-309-55543-4
OCLC
44962338
Statement on responsible collection description
Princeton University Library aims to describe library materials in a manner that is respectful to the individuals and communities who create, use, and are represented in the collections we manage. Read more...
Other views
Staff view